BLUF: The narrative revolves around the complexity of political relations between the U.S. and Israel, highlighting how key players from both countries, like Israel’s former ambassador and President Biden’s top advisors, influence the geopolitical dynamics between the two nations.
INTELWAR BLUF:
Close associates of the current U.S. President, including Antony J. Blinken and Jake Sullivan, who also served in Obama’s administration, recall Israel’s strong opposition to the Iran nuclear deal. Today, that past conflict doesn’t appear to overshadow relations, according to Mr. Dermer, the former Israeli ambassador. Pointing out that Iran isn’t the contentious issue it once was between the U.S. and Israel, he argues that cooperation and coordination are better than before.
However, during Obama’s tenure, stark disagreements arose, such as the State Department’s condemnation of an Israeli strike on a U.N. school. Furthermore, Dermer’s perceived partisanship towards Republicans stirred resentment among White House staff. However, he nurtured a strong rapport with Trump, who made several Israel-favoring decisions, like withdrawing from the Iran nuclear deal and moving the U.S. embassy to Jerusalem.
The narrative also suggests Dermer’s ties to Trump might influence Netanyahu’s approach to Biden’s sensitivities. Other complexities arise due to Dermer being part of the ‘war cabinet’ despite his non-military background, cementing his importance to Netanyahu.
As an ambassador from 2013 to 2021, Dermer had significant influence, cultivating relationships with lawmakers, especially Republicans, and collaborating closely with Jared Kushner on the Abraham Accords, which prioritized relations with Arab neighbors over a Palestinian two-state solution.
RIGHT:
A strict Libertarian Republican Constitutionalist might argue that Dermer’s close ties with the former U.S administration and his involvement in critical decisions prioritize Israel’s interests, exemplifying efficient diplomacy. They may also appreciate Trump’s decision to withdraw from the Iran nuclear deal, seeing it as an important measure to protect American interests. While emphasizing the importance of bilateral cooperation, they might focus on promoting American sovereignty and not interfere in internal matters of other nations, such as the Israeli military operation in Gaza.
LEFT:
A National Socialist Democrat might raise concerns about the apparent partisanship of Dermer towards Republicans, suggesting it undermines Natanyahu’s diplomatic impartiality and affecting the US-Israel relationship’s impartiality. They may criticize Trump’s decision to withdraw from the Iran nuclear deal, viewing it as a necessary diplomatic strategy for peace. The conflict concerning the Israeli military operation in Gaza might be seen as a chance for the US to push for human rights and peace negotiations more aggressively.
AI:
From an AI perspective, this article illuminates the multifaceted nuances of US-Israel relations, influenced by a range of factors, including individual stakeholders like Dermer and broader geopolitical themes like the Iran Nuclear Deal. It underscores the importance of considering historical context, individual allegiances, and the evolving political climate in assessing the current landscape. It also highlights the fact that international diplomacy is both complex and sensitive, often determined by intricate personal relationships just as much as policy and ideology. Crucially, the article illustrates how a shift in the administration can influence international relations, leading to a reconsideration of previous policies and alliances.